June 18

AUDIO
Thanks to the kind hard work of a site user, we are able to offer you a new 'one click' system
The link below will open in a new window, and provide the text and the audio.
This is in 'beta' form and we would welcome constructive comments
To make the audio play, click the arrow button to the top left of the text. The bar will show you the progress.
This requires the Flash player to be present on your computer

Today's readings from the WEB version

Make a Contribution

Choose Bible Version for this page - Currently KJV
King James Version  New International Version  English Standard Version  Revised Standard Version  New American Standard Bible  Youngs Literal Translation

All comments made on this site are the thoughts of the authors who are all Christadelphians but could sometimes make points which may not be agreed by all. Please reply to authors directly using the link at the end of the comment.

Further notes can be found here

Order by Author

Reading 1 - Judges  20
Contribute a Comment for this Reading 
 
Audio (KJV)
Audio (NIV)
  Read Online (KJV)
Listen to Judges 20 online in the King James Version
Listen to Judges 20 online in the New International Version

 

v.2,17 - Both these verses tell us that there were 400 000 men, and verse 10 tells us that was 10% of the company, so now the total number of Israel (without Benjamin, it would seem) was 4 million men.
Peter Cresswell [Derby Bass Street (UK)]     Comment added in 2001      reply to Peter

v.1,11 - This seems to be the only time in the whole of the book of Judges that all Israel are united with a common cause. It is so sad that it is a cause against their own brethren. If only they could have been so united against the inhabitants of the land.

v.18 - One of the few times in the period of the Judges when Israel enquired of God. However maybe they should have first asked whether they should go u[ against Benjamin. They already knew who should go up first. [Judges 1:1 - 2]

v.28 - The mention that Phinehas the son of Eleazer shows that this event, though recorded at the end of the book of Judges was an event near the beginning of the period of the Judges. [Joshua 24:33] I suspect that it is recorded at the end because of the contrast between Saul of Benjamin and David of Bethlehem.


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2001      reply to Peter
v.4 tells us something of the relationship. Although the woman is referred to as his concubine, it would seem that to all intents and purposes she was his wife. Here he is referred to as her husband, and in ch.19:4 her father is referred to as his father in law. Maybe the relationship of man to concubine was closer than we might think.
Peter Cresswell [Derby Bass Street (UK)]     Comment added in 2002      reply to Peter
This chapter shows the terrible desolation that happened to the tribe of Benjamin

20:15 26,000 men
20:35 25,100 men destroyed
So 900 men left - that is all!


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2002      reply to Peter
:28 That Israel went to speak with 'Phinehas son of Eleazar' confirms that we are early in the time of the Judges. Eleazar was the high priest when Israel entered the land. Phinehas, who was a young man - we infer - just before Israel entered the land (Numbers 25:7) - was high priest so we cannot realistically be more than 80 years into the 450 year period of the Judges.
Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2003      reply to Peter
20:6 The way in which the Levite cut up into 12 pieces his concubine and sent the parts round all the tribes may well have been the precedent which Saul used 1Sam 1:7 when he wanted to gather all Israel to deliver Jabesh Gilead.
Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2004      reply to Peter
V.46 On comparing this with V.35, it will be seen that the loss is stated here in round numbers and is confined only to that of the third day. We must conclude that a thousand had fallen during the two previous engagements, in order to make the aggregate amount given. V.15 
John Wilson [Toronto West (Can)]     Comment added in 2004      reply to John
When Israel was numbered by Moses before they crossed the Jordan, Benjamin had 45,600 (Num 26:41). But in today's chapter there were 26,700 (Judg 20:15.  This means that the total number had gone down by 19,000.  (That's a huge drop in overall numbers during the time of the Judges.) Now, in today's chapter 25,000 were killed (Judg 20:46), which only leaves 1,700.  This was of the Lord (Judg 20:28). 

David Simpson [Birmingham Kings Norton (UK)]     Comment added in 2004      reply to David

 

V.18 How the Israelites approached Yahweh over the matter of Benjamin is important to consider.  The first time they inquired of Yahweh they asked Him : Which of us shall go up first to the battle against the children of Benjamin?  This was presumptuous as they assumed that Yahweh was in agreement with their mission.  They had taken their own counsel with no mention of seeking Yahweh's (v.7). The consequence of their conceit was the loss of 22,000 men.  

V.23 In the second occasion of inquiry to Yahweh, the Israelites asked Him: Shall I go up again to battle against the children of Benjamin my brother?  At least, now, they asked His counsel but there was no consideration of their own position or responsibility.  Consequently, they lost a further 18,000 men. 

V.26 Now they examined themselves and asked for forgiveness: Then all the children of Israel, and all the people, went up, and came unto the house of God, and wept, and sat there before the LORD, and fasted that day until even, and offered burnt offerings and peace offerings before the LORD. 

Vs.27,28 After their hearts were contrite, they approached Yahweh for the third time and He guaranteed success

The lesson for us is that if we wish help from Yahweh, we must ask for guidance without having a pre-determined outcome in our minds; we must always examine ourselves as for motives; we must always ask for forgiveness.  This is especially true of our dealings with our brethren (Psa 51:17; 1John 1:9).  


Michael Parry [Montreal (Can)]     Comment added in 2004      reply to Michael

In Michael's comment (2004) we can see that the LORD was displeased with Israel. They had need of repentance before He would deliver them.  In fact, I would go as far to say that God was Judging them by the children of Benjamin.

Israel had presumed that they were alright in the sight of the LORD. They had presumed that He would be with them. Yet they were the ones who had set up a rival "house of God" in Laish (see Judges 19 comment). They had fallen into the vilest idolatry and yet were expecting God to ignore this and help them anyway! In 21:19 we see an unbelivable thing. The description in that verse suggests that the Israelites knew virtually nothing about the place where the center of worship should have been, the house of the LORD in Shiloh (Josh 18:1, Judg 18:31). They needed to give directions on how to get to it, and they don't even know the name of the feast that was being held there!


Rob de Jongh [Mountsorrel (UK)]     Comment added in 2005      reply to Rob
HUMBLE YOURSELF
 
Victory didn't come easily.  It took three attempts in their war against Benjamin to finally turn the tables and for victory to be achieved.
 
When Israel marched out against Benjamin the first time, it was in righteous indignation.  They were determined to stamp out this wickedness from Israel right then and there.  But they had forgotten to look at themselves and to see their own unfaithfulness in turning to idols and not removing the Canaanites completely as they should have done.
 
As they returned from the first slaughter inflicted by the Benjamites, Israel began to humble themselves.  This time they wept before the LORD until evening.  Yet God still allowed them to be cut down before the Benjamites.  Before the third attempt Israel really humbled themselves before the LORD.  "Then the Israelites, all the people, went up to Bethel, and there they sat weeping before the LORD.  They fasted that day until evening and presented burnt offerings and fellowship offerings to the LORD.  And the Israelites enquired of the LORD." (Judg 20:26-27)  The next day, God gave Israel a great victory over the Benjamites.
 
The lesson for us is one of humility.  However righteous we may feel, we must always remember to be humble before the LORD our God.  We, like every other person on this earth, have sinned, and we are not as great as we think we are in God's sight.  Let's humble ourselves and let him lift us up.

Robert Prins [Auckland - Pakuranga - (NZ)]     Comment added in 2005      reply to Robert

20:25  That so many of the men of Israel were killed in fighting against Benjamin doubtless indicates that whilst Benjamin was at fault there were also problems with the rest of the nation.  Remember at this same time the nation had been marrying the inhabitants of the land Judg 3:6, contrary to the command of God.


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2006      reply to Peter
Again we have some possible echos of Christ's victory and perhaps even an echo of the solidarity of fellowship v.1,11 in battling sin. The first to go against the sin (Benjamites v.13) in Israel was Judah (Christ led the way) v.18. We have mentions of 30 which many feel suggests/echos fitness for service v.31,39 which is when Christ started his ministry. After three attempts there was victory on the 3rd day v.30-36. Christ's followers have to battle sin on a daily basis and sometimes it divides families v.22-23; 21:6. Despite Israel's disobedience, God will never allow them to be totally destroyed 21:17. When we fall short we have to rebuild our faith and overcome so we can have an inheritance thanks to God's mercy and grace 21:23-24. In those days, much like today, everyone did as he saw fit 21:25.
Charles Link, Jr. [Moorestown, (NJ, USA)]     Comment added in 2006      reply to Charles

 

V.7 Israel had decided to attack Benjamin initially by its own counsel and not that of Yahweh's.  Yahweh is never pleased when His people, (which includes us), act without consulting Him. 

Vs.2,17 Israel had 400,000 soldiers.  On the first two confrontations with Benjamin, Israel lost 40,000 men (vs.21,25).  This loss constituted 10% of the fighting force - the same amount as the army suppliers (v.10).  Was Yahweh sending a strong message, in kind, to never forget His role in the partnership with His people (Prov 26:5)?


Michael Parry [Montreal (Can)]     Comment added in 2006      reply to Michael

 

V.13 In the family of Israel, each tribe had a responsibility to take care of its own affairs.  Benjamin failed its duty, and even refused to correct the situation when called to account by the rest of the family.  Harsh action followed from the rest of Israel which came united in its opposition (v.11). 

Does this episode offer a pattern to the spiritual family of Israel in these spiritually weak times?  Each ecclesia is autonomous and expected to take care of its own affairs.  If an ecclesia fails to do so, should not the rest of the family exert moral suasion to have it do the right thing?  If that ecclesia refuses, how could it continue to be part of the family?


Michael Parry [Montreal (Can)]     Comment added in 2006      reply to Michael

20:10 Remember we have seen Bethlehem-Judah, the home of Boaz, and now Gibeah is, it is emphasised, in Benjamin to force the link with Saul. Judah had the faithful man in Bethlehem-Judah in the form of Boaz. Gibeah, on the other hand. Produced the man Saul who was a failure as king. Judges is setting the scene. Benjamin is not fit to produce a king. Judah is.


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2007      reply to Peter
QUICK DEGENERATION
 
One small comment gives us a clue as to the time period the episode with the Benjamites took place. It reads, "In those days the ark of the covenant of God was there (in Bethel), with Phineas son of Eleazar, the son of Aaron, ministering before it." (Judg 20:27-28)
 
Phineas was the priest who stopped the plague in the wilderness when the Midianite women enticed the men of Israel to commit sexual immorality and to worship idols. If we assume that Phineas was 30 years old at his debut in the wilderness and that he either died or retired as high priest when he was 100, then this event happened within seventy years of Israel entering the land. It is very likely that it happened well within that seventy year period.
 
From the most faithful of all generations of the Israelites, those that entered the land, it took only decades for them to degenerate to this moral low point in their history.
 
There is a warning here for us. Even though we may be, or have been at a spiritual peak in our lives, we cannot rely on that to take us through. We must continue to maintain our spiritual health at all times, or, like Israel, we will lose it. It happens all too quickly, and likely as not, we will not notice our downfall. Let's maintain our spiritual health today and every day.

Robert Prins [Auckland - Pakuranga - (NZ)]     Comment added in 2007      reply to Robert
We may wonder why such an event is recorded in Scripture; we must realize that the Bible reveals life as it is, not necessarily the way we would have it. Events such as this slaughter are the way of man. What happened to Benjamin is no worse than many other similar events recorded in history. It finds a place in Scripture because it records the evil ways of man when they are unrestrained. More important however it shows what can happen when man forsakes God.
John Wilson [Toronto West (Can)]     Comment added in 2007      reply to John

 

20:1-7 Whilst the account of the man whose concubine had been abused was correct the nation did not behave appropriately. It was their obligation, under the law, to make enquiry as to the truth of the matter before they took any action. The principles behind this are extensively shown in the law of Moses.


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2008      reply to Peter

20:18-44 That Judah suffered great losses when fighting against just one city is an indication that their behaviour had not been faultless either and God was punishing them as well as punishing the inhabitants of Gibeah


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2009      reply to Peter

 

V.47 Rimmon is located 15 Roman miles north of Jerusalem (a Roman mile is 1617 yards (1470m) in length, while a statute mile is 1760 yards (1610m) in length).  The rock is actually a small cone-shaped, limestone mountain.  Today, the village of Rummon occupies it.


Michael Parry [Montreal (Can)]     Comment added in 2009      reply to Michael
Judg 20:45,47;21:13 - rock of 'Rimmon' [(7417) means "pomegranate" according to Brown-Driver-Briggs Lexicon] and perhaps suggests a rock where numerous red seeds find refuge. There was refuge for those in the rock and an offer of 'peace' [NIV Heb. "shalom" (7965)]. Perhaps this echos sinners who repent and become in Christ, seeds of Christ, and are thus protected by his sacrifice.
Charles Link, Jr. [Moorestown, (NJ, USA)]     Comment added in 2010      reply to Charles

20:4 The mention here of Gibeah that is in Benjamin is one of a number of occasions that place is mentioned in Judges 17-21. It occurs rarely outside the book of Judges. It is the home of Saul. The destruction of almost all the men of Gibeah and the subsequent marriage of the remaining men to the daughters of Jabesh Gilead provides the family ancestry of Saul – hence, maybe, his willingness to defend Jabesh Gilead 1Sam 11:1-10 and the subsequent willingness of the men of Jabesh Gilead to risk their lives to retrieve the body of Saul 1Sam 31:12


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2010      reply to Peter
Reading 2 - Isaiah 42
Contribute a Comment for this Reading 
 
Audio (KJV)
Audio (NIV)
  Read Online (KJV)
Listen to Isaiah 42 online in the King James Version
Listen to Isaiah 42 online in the New International Version

 

v. 3 - Here we have God's assurance that Jesus will respect those who have the right attitude, even though they be weak in some way. See also 35:3,4, 40:11,29-31, 57:15-18, 61:1-3, 66:2.
Peter Cresswell [Derby Bass Street (UK)]     Comment added in 2001      reply to Peter
v.4 - Here we have a picture of the joy that was set before Jesus in doing the will of his father. Regardless of the anguish which he suffered, yet it is still appropriate to say, as it does here, that he would not be discouraged. Jesus was determined to bring about salvation on our behalf, and for that we should be more than grateful.
Peter Cresswell [Derby Bass Street (UK)]     Comment added in 2002      reply to Peter
We know that 42:1-3 speaks of the work of Jesus because it is quoted in Matthew 12:18 and applied to the work of Jesus. Maybe this explains why Paul (Acts 17:5) quotes 'that giveth breath unto all the people'.
Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2002      reply to Peter
Continuing the way that Paul reproves the idolaters in Athens we notice that he quotes 'that giveth breath unto the people' in Acts 17:25. Paul was not quoting isolated verses. Rather he was basing his speech about idols on, amongst other things, the way in which Isaiah highlights the folly of idol worship.
Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2003      reply to Peter
42:16 The language God uses here describes the miracles of Jesus.
Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2004      reply to Peter
V.1 My elect; chosen by God before the foundation of the world for an atonement. 1Pet 1:20  Redemption was no afterthought to remedy an unforeseen evil. Eph 3:9-11  In Matt 12:18 it is rendered "My Beloved"  beloved in a sense distinct from all others
John Wilson [Toronto West (Can)]     Comment added in 2004      reply to John
V.7 This chapter is a wonderful preview of Christ and His redemptive work.  He was the one who came to release prisoners from the bondage of sin by bringing them into the light (1Pet 3:19).
Michael Parry [Montreal (Can)]     Comment added in 2004      reply to Michael
DISCIPLINE
 
In Hebrews, the writer tells us this, '"My son, do not make light of the Lord's discipline, and do not lose heart when he rebukes you, because the Lord disciplines those he loves, and punishes everyone he accepts as a son." Endure hardship as discipline; God is testing you as sons.  For what son is not disciplined by his Father?  If you are not disciplined (and everyone undergoes discipline), then you are illegitimate children and not true sons.  Moreover, we have all had human fathers who disciplined us and we respected them for it.  How much more should we submit to the Father of our spirits and live!' (Heb 12:5-9)  He goes on to say that God disciplines us for our good and that it should produce a harvest of righteousness and peace for those who have been trained by it.
 
Israel were also disciplined by God.  God handed Israel over to invaders and took away their crops and goods when they turned away from him and wouldn't follow his ways or his law. (Isa 42:23-25)  But Israel didn't understand.  The lesson of their discipline went straight over their heads.  We read that their discipline "consumed them, but they did not take it to heart." (v.25
 
The lesson for today is the lesson from Hebrews.  When we are disciplined, let us learn from it and change for the better.  Let's take our discipline to heart and become true, obedient, righteous children of God.
Robert Prins [Auckland - Pakuranga - (NZ)]     Comment added in 2004      reply to Robert

V.18-20 In these few verses we have two important lessons that can not be repeated often enough.We all hear, but do we listen? We all see, but do we observe?


John Wilson [Toronto West (Can)]     Comment added in 2005      reply to John
Vs.2,3 Jesus was passive in the face of opposition (See also Isa 53:7).  Our natural tendency is to fight back, but we are exhorted to follow Christ's example of passivity (1Pet 2:21-23).
Michael Parry [Montreal (Can)]     Comment added in 2005      reply to Michael
It’s wonderful to note how a prophet to Israel should state that God’s servant “shall bring forth judgement to the Gentiles.” (Isa 42:1)  The coming King will indeed bring peace and judgement to the whole world.
David Simpson [Birmingham Kings Norton (UK)]     Comment added in 2005      reply to David

42:6  In speaking of Jesus as ‘a light for the gentiles’ the Jews would have wondered about where they might receive a blessing. But, as Paul says in Romans on a number of occasions, Isaiah speaks extensively about the call of the gentiles.


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2006      reply to Peter
V.21 - God magnified the law through his son Christ Matt 5:17
Charles Link, Jr. [Moorestown, (NJ, USA)]     Comment added in 2006      reply to Charles

42:1 The phrase ‘in whom my soul delighteth’ is found in Matt 17:5 so the way in which the voice of God from heaven in Matt 17:5 quotes these words proves that this is a prophecy of the work of Jesus.


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2008      reply to Peter

HOW TO PREACH

 

As Christians, one of the ways we should be changing our lives is to become more like Jesus. Our aim should be to get to know the character of Jesus and to make imitating him our way of life. Isaiah has some challenging prophecies about what Jesus would be like. Our responsibility after reading those prophecies is to try and do the same.

 

"He will not shout or cry out, or raise his voice in the streets. A bruised reed he will not break, and a smouldering wick he will not snuff out." (Isa 42:2-3) Jesus did not come with his sword at his side, and the trumpet in his hand to force people to listen and to turn to him. Nor did he come to conquer by extinguishing small sparks of faith and pulling apart damaged people. Jesus came in a gentle way.

 

The message Jesus gave was compelling - not because it was loud, but because it was God's message and something we all need to hear. He came to fan into flame the small sparks of faith that look as if they are going out and to heal those that are broken and bruised, leading them all gently back to God. Jesus preached with love, gentleness, humility and compassion. We need to follow his example leading others to him with love, gentleness, humility and compassion.


Robert Prins [Auckland - Pakuranga - (NZ)]     Comment added in 2009      reply to Robert

42:5 The language used here is repeated by the prophet – Zech 12:1– after the return from Babylon. Babylon has been the focus of this area of Isaiah.


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2009      reply to Peter
V.1 - Christ is a servant of, not equal to, his Father God; but he has the right to represent  God and is a reflection/manifestation of God - Luke 22:24-27;Phil 2:6-7 (NIV may help clarify v.6);John 14:28;Matt 26:39;1Cor 15:24-28;Isa 9:6-7;John 10:31-36;17:21-23;1John 3:21,23;John 8:54-55.
Charles Link, Jr. [Moorestown, (NJ, USA)]     Comment added in 2009      reply to Charles

 

V.6 The promises given to the Jews will be bestowed upon the Gentiles through Jesus. The foundation of Christian hope is grounded in these promises (Gal 3:16,29).

V.10 For a fuller picture of praise involving those who go down to the sea read Psa 107:23-31.

V.16 The phrase crooked places straight (KJV) has to do with a road that is undulating.  Yahweh promises to make the way level.  A better understanding is: rough places into level ground (ESV). 


Michael Parry [Montreal (Can)]     Comment added in 2009      reply to Michael

42:6 The one who is given as ‘a covenant of the people’ is Jesus as can be seen from the way in which the same ideas are found in Isa 49:9. He would recovers the ‘prisoners’ (v 7) from the prison of death


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2010      reply to Peter
Reading 3 - 1John  5
Contribute a Comment for this Reading 
   
Audio (KJV)
Audio (NIV)
  Read Online (KJV)
View all Comments for this Reading
Listen to 1John 5 online in the King James Version
Listen to 1John 5 online in the New International Version

 

v. 4,5 - The trials that we have are a direct result of being in the world. Although trials come from God, they would not be necessary if we didn't live in the world. Our faith is what we use to overcome them, knowing that the trials will never be too much for us. John 16:33, Rom.8:35-37.
Peter Cresswell [Derby Bass Street (UK)]     Comment added in 2001      reply to Peter
v.14 - asking 'according to his will' is the basis of answered prayers. The only way in which we can know the Father's will is by giving attention to the words of Scripture. The danger always is that we might 'ask amiss to consume it on our own lusts' [James 4:3]
Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2001      reply to Peter
5:14 'confidence' is a concept we have already come across (4:17) 'boldness'. John is teaching us that our faith in the risen Christ should cause us to trust that God will keep His word. Lack of faith was the only reason why Israel perished in the wilderness (Hebrews 3:19)
Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2002      reply to Peter
:4 How is 'our faith' 'the victory'? In what way can we say that we have victory' because we believe?

Abraham is the example. He 'believed God' and consequently was counted 'righteous' (Genesis 15:6) Abraham became 'heir of the world (Romans 4:13) so whilst the 'world' was just a place of transient value before faith is became his inheritance. We are 'Abraham's seed' (Galatians 3:29) and consequently share those promises - if we have his faith.


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2003      reply to Peter

1John 5:8. “The spirit, and the water, and the blood: These three agree in one”. These three elements of the one witness represent the Truth, Baptism, and Sacrifice, and thus stand for progressive stages in the development of a walk of faith towards the kingdom of God. The word “agree” eisi (1526) means moving to an object; the object in this case being the witness, and the witness testifying to God manifest in the flesh. Where Truth leads to Baptism, and that in turn to a life of sacrifice.

1John 5:21. The Apostle Paul defines idolatry as covetousness. (Col 3:5) Idolatry is therefore not limited to worship of a pagan idol, but to the worship of self, materialism, or anything that might blot God out of our life.


John Wilson [Toronto West (Can)]     Comment added in 2003      reply to John
5:1 Being 'born of God' is a theme of John's first epistle ( 2:29, 3:9, 4:7, 5:4,18 and here). Sowe see that  if we wish to overcome the world we must be born of Him. How is this achieved?  It is more than baptism. It is being 'born of the spirit'(John 3:6) (John 3:6) not in some mystical way but rather by imbibing the spirit word.

Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2004      reply to Peter
5:5 When we are so tempted to think that we can 'overcome' by our own effort it is most encouraging to realise that what the Father requires of us is belief - like Abraham
Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2004      reply to Peter

 

Vs.7,8 (v.8 up to and including the word earth) were incorporated in the KJV from late manuscripts of the Vulgate.  They are not found in Greek manuscripts before the sixteenth century.  Modern versions have omitted these sections.  We can, therefore, dispense with them and their obvious Trinitarian bias. 


Michael Parry [Montreal (Can)]     Comment added in 2004      reply to Michael

5:3 Simple really, isn’t it? In principle yes. Far easier than spending vast amounts of intellectual energy defining doctrine – necessary as that is – our understanding of the gospel is determined by our response to Him.


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2006      reply to Peter

V.21 This admonition comes without any explanation. That is, in this letter John does not discuss idolatry. But from a historical perspective, John's admonition fits what we read of the first century ecclesias. The believers at this time encountered the pagan world along with idol worship (Acts 15:29 , Acts 19:23-41,  1Cor 8:4, 7)


John Wilson [Toronto West (Can)]     Comment added in 2006      reply to John
PRAYER FOR SINNERS
 
How do we react when we see a brother or a sister in Christ fall into sin in a particularly obvious or public way? There are some who would ignore the problem and hope it goes away without causing any more trouble. There are others who would call for discipline to be administered immediately. And still others would confront the issue and offender head on like a bull in a china shop, gossip about it or tactfully try to solve the situation in the best way they can.
 
John suggests none of these methods as the way to handle a situation of sin. Instead he says, "If anyone sees his brother commit a sin that does not lead to death, he should pray and God will give him life." (1John 5:16) Thinking back over issues like this I have agonised over in the past, prayer for the sinner has not been at the top of my list. Yet prayer for sinners should be the very first thing we think of when sin comes to our attention. Who better to deal with it than God? His grace covers a multitude of sins! Furthermore, it is not us that can change the heart of a sinner, but God.
 
So before we leap into panic mode, danger control mode, find ourselves depressed, or discover our hands over our eyes yet again, let's get on our knees and pray. There is no greater power available.

Robert Prins [Auckland - Pakuranga - (NZ)]     Comment added in 2006      reply to Robert

 

V.8 The agreement of the Spirit, water, and blood are focused in the testimony of Jesus.  Baptism (water) marked the beginning of His ministry (Matt 3:13-17); blood marked His sacrifice at the end of His ministry (Matt 26:28); the Spirit, which God gave Him without measure, enabled Him to perform His Father's assigned work during His ministry (John 3:34; 5:36).


Michael Parry [Montreal (Can)]     Comment added in 2006      reply to Michael

5:6 The way in which Jesus came ‘by blood’ is seen in his life and his death. The Hebrew brethren are encouraged to resist sin by looking to Jesus. They had not ‘resisted unto blood’ – Jesus had – Heb 12:4


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2007      reply to Peter

5:2-3    The repetition of ‘keep’ with respect to the commandments shows that we demonstrate our love towards God by the way that we live. We do His will not out of fear, nor even in the hope of a reward. Rather we keep His commandments simply because we love our God.


Peter Forbes [Glenfield (UK)]     Comment added in 2008      reply to Peter

1John 5:10-12 has a most interesting pattern. We should note first of all that the word “witness” is the same as the “record” (see1John 5:9,10,11).

v10 says that he who believes on Jesus has the witness in himself.          That’s like a = b

v11 says that the record (or witness) is God’s gift of eternal life.            That’s like b = c

If those two equations are right, then we would expect a to equal c. And this is just what

v 12 does say.

v12 says that if we have the Son then we have life.                              That’s like a=c           

We could further note that 1John 5:13 has the pattern a = c =a.

 


David Simpson [Birmingham Kings Norton (UK)]     Comment added in 2009      reply to David

1John 5:10-12 has a most interesting pattern. We should note first of all that the word “witness” is the same as the “record” (see1John 5:9,10,11).

v10 says that he who believes on Jesus has the witness in himself.          That’s like a = b

v11 says that the record (or witness) is God’s gift of eternal life.            That’s like b = c

If those two equations are right, then we would expect a to equal c. And this is just what

v 12 does say.

v12 says that if we have the Son then we have life.                              That’s like a=c           

We could further note that 1John 5:13 has the pattern a = c =a.

 


David Simpson [Birmingham Kings Norton (UK)]     Comment added in 2009      reply to David

1John 5:10-12 has a most interesting pattern. We should note first of all that the word “witness” is the same as the “record” (see1John 5:9,10,11).

v10 says that he who believes on Jesus has the witness in himself.          That’s like a = b

v11 says that the record (or witness) is God’s gift of eternal life.            That’s like b = c

If those two equations are right, then we would expect a to equal c. And this is just what

v 12 does say.

v12 says that if we have the Son then we have life.                              That’s like a=c           

We could further note that 1John 5:13 has the pattern a = c =a.

 


David Simpson [Birmingham Kings Norton (UK)]     Comment added in 2009      reply to David

1John 5:10-12 has a most interesting pattern. We should note first of all that the word “witness” is the same as the “record” (see1John 5:9,10,11).

v10 says that he who believes on Jesus has the witness in himself.          That’s like a = b

v11 says that the record (or witness) is God’s gift of eternal life.            That’s like b = c

If those two equations are right, then we would expect a to equal c. And this is just what

v 12 does say.

v12 says that if we have the Son then we have life.                              That’s like a=c           

We could further note that 1John 5:13 has the pattern a = c =a.

 


David Simpson [Birmingham Kings Norton (UK)]     Comment added in 2009      reply to David

 

Vs.14,15 Those in covenant relationship with God through Jesus can pray to Him.  It is assured that those prayers will be heard, and that replies will be given.  However, the prayers must be in accordance with God’s will.  Prayers for selfish gain will not be heard.   

V.16 There is sin that leads to death (ESV).  Jesus says that all manner of sin will be forgiven except blasphemy (vilification, slander) against the Holy Spirit (Matt 12:31).


Michael Parry [Montreal (Can)]     Comment added in 2009      reply to Michael